WPC 2{BmR y3|G"^6HXllHHHlz6H6],5,,YYYYYYYYYY,,]]]Ykkttkb|t,PkYt|k|tkbtkkkb,,,KY$YYPYY,YY$$P$YYYY5P,YPtPPP5*5]5,555555555555b,kYkYkYkYkYtPkYkYkYkY,,,,,,,,tY|Y|Y|Y|YtYtYtYtYkPkYtY|b|YkPkYkYkYtPtPtPtPtYkYkYkYkY|Y|Y|Y|Y|Y|YtYtY,,,,,$,,PkPY$Y$Y$Y$Y$tYtYtYtY|Y|Yt5t5t5kPkPkPkPb,b,b,tYtYtYtYtYtYtkPbPbPbPtYY$tYt5kPb,kPkPtY|YtYK8,VY5bYYYYY;:YvvY55Y55YYPP$52j ;mDm"^?Sf}}SSS}?S?F}}}}}}}}}}FFo浧Sa޵쵵SFSu}So}o}oS}}FF}F}}}}SaF}}}}ox2xS?SS*SSSSSSSSSS}FoooooާoooooSFSFSFSF}}}}}}}}}}o}}}}ooooooo}oooo}}}}}}}}SFSFSFSFa}FFFFF}}}}}}޵SSSaaaaFFF}}}}}}쵵}ooo}F}SaF}}}}}"^(1<PPCPP(PPPPPPPPPPCխxCCCCCCCCxxxxxxCCCCC5CCxx55555PPPxxxxCCC㭠xxxx5PxCxxKTCPYX.PPPPxx5P"^(1<=]{{] 88]88]]SS%8"m^%%/JJwY,,4N%,%%JJJJJJJJJJ%%NNNJYY``YQh`%CYJo`hYh`YQ`Y~YYQ%%%?JJJCJJ%JJCoJJJJ,C%JC`CCC-#-N,%,,,,,,,,,,,,Q%YJYJYJYJYJw`CYJYJYJYJ%%%%%%%%`JhJhJhJhJ`J`J`J`JYCYJ`JhQhJYCYJYJYJ`C`C`C`C`JYJYJYJYJhJhJhJhJhJhJ`J`J%%%%%%%CYCJJJJJ`J`J`J`JhJhJ~`,`,`,YCYCYCYCQ%Q%Q%`J`J`J`J`J`J~`YCQCQCQC`JJ`J`,YCQ%YCYC`JhJ`JK/%HJ,QJJJJJ11JbbJ,,J,,JJCC,"m^..;]]o%88Aa.8..]]]]]]]]]]..aaa]ooxxofx.So]xoxofxooof...N]%YY``YQh`%CYJo`hYh`YQ`Y~YYQ8+8a8.888888888888f.o]o]o]o]o]xSo]o]o]o]........x]]]]]x]x]x]x]oSo]x]f]oSo]o]o]xSxSxSxSx]o]o]o]o]]]]]]]x]x].....%..SoS]%]%]%]%]%x]x]x]x]]]x8x8x8oSoSoSoSf.f.f.x]x]x]x]x]x]xoSfSfSfSx]]%x]x8oSf.oSoSx]]x]K:.Z]8f]]]]]>=]{{] 88]88]]SS%82526.3/41>d3"m^.8O]]x.88Aa.8..]]]]]]]]]]88aaafxxxxofx.]xfxoxofxooof8.8a].]f]f]8ff..].ffffA]8f]]]SA/Aa8.888888888888f.x]x]x]x]x]x]o]o]o]o]........xfffffxfxfxfxfo]x]xfffo]x]x]x]x]x]x]x]xfo]o]o]o]ffffffxfxf........]x]f.f.f.f.f.xfxfxfxfffxAxAxAo]o]o]o]f8f8f8xfxfxfxfxfxfo]fSfSfSxff.xfxAo]f8o]o]xffxfK:.]]8f]]]]]>=]{{](SS]88]]ff.S"m^%,?JJw`%,,4N%,%%JJJJJJJJJJ,,NNNQ````YQh`%J`Qo`hYh`YQ`Y~YYQ,%,NJ%JQJQJ,QQ%%J%wQQQQ4J,QJhJJC4%4N,%,,,,,,,,,,,,Q%`J`J`J`J`Jw`JYJYJYJYJ%%%%%%%%`QhQhQhQhQ`Q`Q`Q`QYJ`J`QhQhQYJ`J`J`J`J`J`J`J`QYJYJYJYJhQhQhQhQhQhQ`Q`Q%%%%%%%%J`JQ%Q%Q%Q%Q%`Q`Q`Q`QhQhQ~`4`4`4YJYJYJYJQ,Q,Q,`Q`Q`Q`Q`Q`Q~hYJQCQCQC`QQ%`Q`4YJQ,YJYJ`QhQ`QK/%JJ,QJJJJJ11JbbJ CCJ,,JJQQ%C"m^.8O]]x.88Aa.8..]]]]]]]]]]88aaafxxxxofx.]xfxoxofxooof8.8a].````YQh`%J`Qo`hYh`YQ`Y~YYQA/Aa8.888888888888f.x]x]x]x]x]x]o]o]o]o]........xfffffxfxfxfxfo]x]xfffo]x]x]x]x]x]x]x]xfo]o]o]o]ffffffxfxf........]x]f.f.f.f.f.xfxfxfxfffxAxAxAo]o]o]o]f8f8f8xfxfxfxfxfxfo]fSfSfSxff.xfxAo]f8o]o]xffxfK:.]]8f]]]]]>=]{{](SS]88]]ff.S"m^?S}}SSS}?S?F}}}}}}}}}}SS}鵧a}çÙõSFS}S}ooS}FSFЋ}oaS}}}oc7cS?SS*SSSSSSSSSSF}}}}}oooooaFaFaFaF}}}}}}}}}}}}oooooooo}}}}}}ËËaFaFaFaF}ËFFFFF}}oooaaaaSSS}oooFoaS}}}KX?}S}}}}}}KS}}F}}}SS}}S}28<@P5A 7B8C~:"m^4EthhЮEEEhw4E4:hhhhhhhhhhEEwwwh–QhŖtЖE:EyhEht]t]Eht:Et:thtt]QEthhh]R.RlE4EE#EEEEEEEEEEt:hhhhhЖ]]]]]Q:Q:Q:Q:thhhhtttthhthhhhhh]]]]t]]]]hhhhhhttQ:Q:Q:Q:ht:::::tttthhЖ]]]tQtQtQtQEEEttttttЖh]]]t:t]tQEhhthtKI4qhEhhhhhh?Ehh:hhhEEhhttEh"m^*8]SS888S_*8*.SSSSSSSSSS88___SxoxxofASoxfx]oxxxxo8.8aS8S]J]J8S].8].]S]]JA8]SxSSJB%BW8*888888888888].xSxSxSxSxSxxJoJoJoJoJA.A.A.A.x]SSSSx]x]x]x]xSxSx]SSxSxSxSxSxJxJxJxJx]oJoJoJoJSSSSSS]]A.A.A.A.S]o.o.o.o.o.x]x]x]x]SSxxJxJxJ]A]A]A]Ao8o8o8x]x]x]x]x]x]xxSoJoJoJx]o.x]xJ]Ao8xSxSx]Sx]K:*ZS8SSSSSS27S}}S.SSS88SS]]8S"m^4EthhЮEEEhw4E4:hhhhhhhhhhEEwwwh–QhŖtЖE:EyhExoxxofASoxfx]oxxxxoR.RlE4EE#EEEEEEEEEEt:hhhhhЖ]]]]]Q:Q:Q:Q:thhhhtttthhthhhhhh]]]]t]]]]hhhhhhttQ:Q:Q:Q:ht:::::tttthhЖ]]]tQtQtQtQEEEttttttЖh]]]t:t]tQEhhthtKI4qhEhhhhhh?Ehh:hhhEEhhttEh"m^**5SSd!22:X*2**SSSSSSSSSS**XXXSddlld\ul*KdS}luduld\lddd\***FS!SSKSS*SS!!K!}SSSS2K*SKlKKK2'2X2*222222222222\*dSdSdSdSdSlKdSdSdSdS********lSuSuSuSuSlSlSlSlSdKdSlSu\uSdKdSdSdSlKlKlKlKlSdSdSdSdSuSuSuSuSuSuSlSlS*****!**KdKS!S!S!S!S!lSlSlSlSuSuSl2l2l2dKdKdKdK\*\*\*lSlSlSlSlSlSldK\K\K\KlSS!lSl2dK\*dKdKlSuSlSK5*QS2\SSSSS87SooS22S22SSKK!22kBLmj<Rm=SmD?E@"^(5APP|555PZ(5(,PPPPPPPPPP,,ZZZGtkktbYtt5>tbttYtkYbttttb5,5KP5GPGPG5PP,,P,|PPPP5>,PPtPPGM MW5(555555555555P,tGtGtGtGtGkkGbGbGbGbG5,5,5,5,tPtPtPtPtPtPtPtPtPtPtGtPtPtPtPtGtGtGkGkGkGkGtPbGbGbGbGtPtPtPtPtPtPtPtP5,5,5,5,>tPb,b,b,b,b,tPtPtPtPtPtPtk5k5k5Y>Y>Y>Y>b,b,b,tPtPtPtPtPtPttPbGbGbGtPb,tPk5Y>b,tPtPtPtPtP"^ +4@@kd+++@H + $@@@@@@@@@@$$HHH9v]VV]NG]]+2]Nr]]G]VGN]]y]]N+$+<@+9@9@9+@@$$@$d@@@@+2$@@]@@9>>E+ ++++++++++++@$]9]9]9]9]9rVV9N9N9N9N9+$+$+$+$]@]@]@]@]@]@]@]@]@]@]9]@]@]@]@]9]9]9V9V9V9V9]@N9N9N9N9]@]@]@]@]@]@]@]@+$+$+$+$2]@N$N$N$N$N$]@]@]@]@]@]@r]V+V+V+G2G2G2G2N$N$N$]@]@]@]@]@]@y]]@N9N9N9]@N$]@V+G2N$]@]@]@]@]@"^(5APP|555PZ(5(,PPPPPPPPPP,,ZZZGtkktbYtt5>tbttYtkYbttttb5,5KP5]VV]NG]]+2]Nr]]G]VGN]]y]]NM MW5(555555555555P,tGtGtGtGtGkkGbGbGbGbG5,5,5,5,tPtPtPtPtPtPtPtPtPtPtGtPtPtPtPtGtGtGkGkGkGkGtPbGbGbGbGtPtPtPtPtPtPtPtP5,5,5,5,>tPb,b,b,b,b,tPtPtPtPtPtPtk5k5k5Y>Y>Y>Y>b,b,b,tPtPtPtPtPtPttPbGbGbGtPb,tPk5Y>b,tPtPtPtPtP"m^(C<(((x((((((((((C!WP|kt|b|tYkttttk5,5]P5PYGYG5PY,5Y,YPYYG>5YPtPPG?#?S5(555555555555Y,tPtPtPtPtPttGkGkGkGkG>,>,>,>,tY|P|P|P|PtYtYtYtYtPtPtY|P|PtPtPtPtPtGtGtGtGtYkGkGkGkG|P|P|P|P|P|P|Y|Y>,>,>,>,P|Yk,k,k,k,k,tYtYtYtY|P|PttGtGtGY>Y>Y>Y>k5k5k5tYtYtYtYtYtYttPkGkGkGtYk,tYtGY>k5tPtPtY|PtYK8(VP5PPPPPP05PxxP,PPP55PPYY5P"m^ +G@@k+++@I + $@@@@@@@@@@++III@w]V]]VNdd2@dVy]dNd]GV]]]]V+$+K@+@G9G9+@G$+G$kG@GG92+G@]@@933C+ ++++++++++++G$]@]@]@]@]@]]9V9V9V9V92$2$2$2$]Gd@d@d@d@]G]G]G]G]@]@]Gd@d@]@]@]@]@]9]9]9]9]GV9V9V9V9d@d@d@d@d@d@dGdG2$2$2$2$@dGV$V$V$V$V$]G]G]G]Gd@d@]]9]9]9G2G2G2G2V+V+V+]G]G]G]G]G]G]]@V9V9V9]GV$]G]9G2V+]@]@]Gd@]GK- E@+@@@@@@'*@``@$@@@++@@GG+@"m^(5YPP555P[(5(,PPPPPPPPPP55[[[Ptkttkb||>P|kt|b|tYkttttk5,5]P5]V]]VNdd2@dVy]dNd]GV]]]]V?#?S5(555555555555Y,tPtPtPtPtPttGkGkGkGkG>,>,>,>,tY|P|P|P|PtYtYtYtYtPtPtY|P|PtPtPtPtPtGtGtGtGtYkGkGkGkG|P|P|P|P|P|P|Y|Y>,>,>,>,P|Yk,k,k,k,k,tYtYtYtY|P|PttGtGtGY>Y>Y>Y>k5k5k5tYtYtYtYtYtYttPkGkGkGtYk,tYtGY>k5tPtPtY|PtYK8(VP5PPPPPP05PxxP,PPP55PPYY5P2WXPZ>R[S\mU"m^P|kt|b|tYkttttkO,OhC2CC!CCCCCCCCCCo8dddddȐYYYYYN8N8N8N8oddddooooddoddddddYYYYoYYYYddddddooN8N8N8N8do88888ooooddȐYYYoNoNoNoNCCCooooooȐdYYYo8oYoNCddodoKF2ldCddddddtbttYtkYbttttb`(`lC2CC!CCCCCCCCCCd8YYYYYYzYzYzYzYC8C8C8C8ddddddddddYddddYYYYYYYdzYzYzYzYddddddddC8C8C8C8Ndz8z8z8z8z8ddddddCCCoNoNoNoNz8z8z8dddddddzYzYzYdz8dCoNz8ddddd2]mmQW]X^xZ_2\"^6lllllͤ`hhhhI>I>I>I>~vvvvxlxvxlll````hhhhxxxxxx~~I>I>I?I>Hx?????~~~~vvسVVVr\r\r\r\GGGٵxlll?~Vr\Gxxv"m^2CTddCCCd2C28ddddddddddCCdzzzzCYozzdozzooN8NTdCddYdY8dd88Y8ddddNN8dYYYNP7PlC2CC!CCCCCCCCCCd8zdzdzdzdzdYzYzYzYzYC8C8C8C8dddddddddoYzddddoYzdzdzdYYYYdzYzYzYzYddddddddC8C8C8C8YYo8o8o8o8o8ddddddzNzNzNdNdNdNdNo8o8o8ddddddoYoNoNoNdo8dzNdNo8oYoYdddKF2idNdddddd7>dd+oodCCddddCo"m^ 22P<#522222222225552[<,>DP5PPGPG,PP,,G,tPPPP>>,PGkGG>@,@W5(555555555555P,bPbPbPbPbPkkGbGbGbGbG5,5,5,5,kPtPtPtPtPtPtPtPtPYGbPtPtPtPYGbPbPbPkGkGkGkGtPbGbGbGbGtPtPtPtPtPtPtPtP5,5,5,5,GkGY,Y,Y,Y,Y,kPkPkPkPtPtPkb>b>b>P>P>P>P>Y,Y,Y,tPtPtPtPtPtPkYGY>Y>Y>tPY,kPb>P>Y,YGYGtPtPtPK8(TP>PPPPPP,2PzzP"YYP55PPPP5Y"m^*2GSSl*22:X*2**SSSSSSSSSS22XXX\lllld\ul*Sl\}luduld\lddd\2*2XS*S\S\S2\\**S*\\\\:S2\SuSSK:*:X2*222222222222\*lSlSlSlSlSlSdSdSdSdS********l\u\u\u\u\l\l\l\l\dSlSl\u\u\dSlSlSlSlSlSlSlSl\dSdSdSdSu\u\u\u\u\u\l\l\********SlS\*\*\*\*\*l\l\l\l\u\u\l:l:l:dSdSdSdS\2\2\2l\l\l\l\l\l\udS\K\K\Kl\\*l\l:dS\2dSdSl\u\l\K5*SS2\SSSSS87SooS$KKS22SS\\*K"m^!!+CCkP((/F!(!!CCCCCCCCCC!!FFFCzPPWWPI]W!],5,,YYYYYYYYYY55]]]bttttkb|t,Ytbt|k|tkbtkkkb5,5]Y,YbYbY5bb,,Y,bbbb>Y5bY|YYP>->]5,555555555555b,tYtYtYtYtYtYkYkYkYkY,,,,,,,,tb|b|b|b|btbtbtbtbkYtYtb|b|bkYtYtYtYtYtYtYtYtbkYkYkYkY|b|b|b|b|b|btbtb,,,,,,,,YtYb,b,b,b,b,tbtbtbtb|b|bt>t>t>kYkYkYkYb5b5b5tbtbtbtbtbtb|kYbPbPbPtbb,tbt>kYb5kYkYtb|btbK8,YY5bYYYYY;:YvvY&PPY55YYbb,P2 le8egfhhifj"m^8C_oo8CCNu8C88ooooooooooCCuuuzÐz8ozzzC8Cuo8ttttkb|t,Ytbt|k|tkbtkkkbN8NuC8CC!CCCCCCCCCCz8oooooȲooooo88888888zzzzzzzzzoozzzoooooooozoooozzzzzzzz88888888ooz8z8z8z8z8zzzzzzȽNNNoooozCzCzCzzzzzzozdzdzdzz8zNozCoozzzKF8ooCzoooooJIoo0ddoCCoozz8d"m^..;]]o%88Aa.8..]]]]]]]]]]..aaa]ooxxofx.So]xoxofxooof...N]%]]S]].]]%%S%]]]]8S.]SxSSS8+8a8.888888888888f.o]o]o]o]o]xSo]o]o]o]........x]]]]]x]x]x]x]oSo]x]f]oSo]o]o]xSxSxSxSx]o]o]o]o]]]]]]]x]x].....%..SoS]%]%]%]%]%x]x]x]x]]]x8x8x8oSoSoSoSf.f.f.x]x]x]x]x]x]xoSfSfSfSx]]%x]x8oSf.oSoSx]]x]K:.Z]8f]]]]]>=]{{] 88]88]]SS%8"m^.8O]]x.88Aa.8..]]]]]]]]]]88aaafxxxxofx.]xfxoxofxooof8.8a].]f]f]8ff..].ffffA]8f]]]SA/Aa8.888888888888f.x]x]x]x]x]x]o]o]o]o]........xfffffxfxfxfxfo]x]xfffo]x]x]x]x]x]x]x]xfo]o]o]o]ffffffxfxf........]x]f.f.f.f.f.xfxfxfxfffxAxAxAo]o]o]o]f8f8f8xfxfxfxfxfxfo]fSfSfSxff.xfxAo]f8o]o]xffxfK:.]]8f]]]]]>=]{{](SS]88]]ff.S"m^%,?JJw`%,,4N%,%%JJJJJJJJJJ,,NNNQ````YQh`%J`Qo`hYh`YQ`Y~YYQ,%,NJ%JQJQJ,QQ%%J%wQQQQ4J,QJhJJC4%4N,%,,,,,,,,,,,,Q%`J`J`J`J`Jw`JYJYJYJYJ%%%%%%%%`QhQhQhQhQ`Q`Q`Q`QYJ`J`QhQhQYJ`J`J`J`J`J`J`J`QYJYJYJYJhQhQhQhQhQhQ`Q`Q%%%%%%%%J`JQ%Q%Q%Q%Q%`Q`Q`Q`QhQhQ~`4`4`4YJYJYJYJQ,Q,Q,`Q`Q`Q`Q`Q`Q~hYJQCQCQC`QQ%`Q`4YJQ,YJYJ`QhQ`QK/%JJ,QJJJJJ11JbbJ CCJ,,JJQQ%C2:sjRlk nlorq"m^.8O]]x.88Aa.8..]]]]]]]]]]88aaafxxxxofx.]xfxoxofxooof8.8a].````YQh`%J`Qo`hYh`YQ`Y~YYQA/Aa8.888888888888f.x]x]x]x]x]x]o]o]o]o]........xfffffxfxfxfxfo]x]xfffo]x]x]x]x]x]x]x]xfo]o]o]o]ffffffxfxf........]x]f.f.f.f.f.xfxfxfxfffxAxAxAo]o]o]o]f8f8f8xfxfxfxfxfxfo]fSfSfSxff.xfxAo]f8o]o]xffxfK:.]]8f]]]]]>=]{{](SS]88]]ff.S"m^%%/JJwY,,4N%,%%JJJJJJJJJJ%%NNNJYY``YQh`%CYJo`hYh`YQ`Y~YYQ%%%?JJJCJJ%JJCoJJJJ,C%JC`CCC-#-N,%,,,,,,,,,,,,Q%YJYJYJYJYJw`CYJYJYJYJ%%%%%%%%`JhJhJhJhJ`J`J`J`JYCYJ`JhQhJYCYJYJYJ`C`C`C`C`JYJYJYJYJhJhJhJhJhJhJ`J`J%%%%%%%CYCJJJJJ`J`J`J`JhJhJ~`,`,`,YCYCYCYCQ%Q%Q%`J`J`J`J`J`J~`YCQCQCQC`JJ`J`,YCQ%YCYC`JhJ`JK/%HJ,QJJJJJ11JbbJ,,J,,JJCC,"m^..;]]o%88Aa.8..]]]]]]]]]]..aaa]ooxxofx.So]xoxofxooof...N]%YY``YQh`%CYJo`hYh`YQ`Y~YYQ8+8a8.888888888888f.o]o]o]o]o]xSo]o]o]o]........x]]]]]x]x]x]x]oSo]x]f]oSo]o]o]xSxSxSxSx]o]o]o]o]]]]]]]x]x].....%..SoS]%]%]%]%]%x]x]x]x]]]x8x8x8oSoSoSoSf.f.f.x]x]x]x]x]x]xoSfSfSfSx]]%x]x8oSf.oSoSx]]x]K:.Z]8f]]]]]>=]{{] 88]88]]SS%8"m^6``t&::Ce0:00``````````00eee`tt}}tj}0Wt`}t}tj}tttj000Q`&``W``0``&&W&````:W0`W}WWW:-:e:0::::::::::::j0t`t`t`t`t`}Wt`t`t`t`00000000}`````}`}`}`}`tWt`}`j`tWt`t`t`}W}W}W}W}`t`t`t`t```````}`}`00000&00WtW`&`&`&`&`&}`}`}`}```}:}:}:tWtWtWtWj0j0j0}`}`}`}`}`}`}tWjWjWjW}``&}`}:tWj0tWtW}``}`K=0]`:j`````@?``!::`::``WW&:2d~R"m^<``t&::Ce0:00``````````00eee`tt}}tj}0Wt`}t}tj}tttj000Q`&``W``0``&&W&````:W0`W}WWW:-:e:0::::::::::::j0t`t`t`t`t`}Wt`t`t`t`00000000}`````}`}`}`}`tWt`}`j`tWt`t`t`}W}W}W}W}`t`t`t`t```````}`}`00000&00WtW`&`&`&`&`&}`}`}`}```}:}:}:tWtWtWtWj0j0j0}`}`}`}`}`}`}tWjWjWjW}``&}`}:tWj0tWtW}``}`K=0]`:j`````@?``!::`::``WW&:"m^<gn|}||||||||````````````g|n|XR{nnnRRnnnnnnnRRRRRRRRRRRRXX"^22 C2222222222CCC Z d dCC FZ)d2FmdmFdZ mFFFCCYFFFFFF )2222mFFFFmmmmFFdFFFFFF))))d2222FFFFFFmmZdmmmmFFd d d d mmmmmm Fddddmd FFdFmKC    22222   mm"^CYmYYYCYCJJJvYhYJY}YwGSww5YCYY -YYYYYYYYYYJvvvvvvvvvvYJYJYJYJvvvvvvvvvvvvYJYJYJYJhJJJJJYYYhhhhJJJvvvJYhJ"^dM7ddooop!  !!!!d!!! !!z!!oooo7o!PdCo!!!!!d  oooo!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!    !!!!!!!!!oooo!ooooo!!!!!!d!   ooo!!!!!!z!!!o! o!!!!!2F6RPRR"^h[Dhhttt-----r-------ttttDt-ShFt-----rtttt---------------------------tttt-ttttt------r-ttt---------t-t-----"^(   0          000 ddF dF)dd6  )) ))) )))   uY)     dddd)    ))))  )      )dddd      )) )ddddd))))  ))))ddd)))))) ddd)d))d  ) )K               )) "^kckkw444LLL4LL44444wwwc4^kGw4444444wwww4LLLL4444444LL444444444LLLLLLLLwwwwLwwwww4444LL4444444444444w44444L4Kk??w"^(   0          000 ddF dF)dd6 444LLL4LL44444uY)     dddd)    ))))  )      )dddd      )) )ddddd))))  ))))ddd)))))) ddd)d))d  ) )K               )) 2"Rx$R&R'Rn"^CY YYYCYCJYYh YJYYvvYJYJvhYvi;iYCYY -YYYYYYYYYYJ vvvvvhJhJhJhJvvvvvvvvhJhJhJhJJJJJJ vvvhhhhYYY vvvJvhYK]CYPXJ YY  Y "^CY YYYCYCJYYh YJYYSkwi;iYCYY -YYYYYYYYYYJ vvvvvhJhJhJhJvvvvvvvvhJhJhJhJJJJJJ vvvhhhhYYY vvvJvhYK]CYPXJ YY  Y "^dMddot! !! 777 z!77! !!!! oooM!XdCo!!!!!!!    oooo!7777!!!!!!!77!!!!!!!!!    77777777oooo7 o o o o o!!!!77!!!!   !!!!!!!!   ! o!! !!!7!Kdx++o"^Pk@ kkkPkPYkk*|.@kYkkkYkY |k~F~kPkk@5kkkkkkkkkkY@|Y|Y|Y|Y|Y|Y|Y|YYYYYY@||||kkk@Y|kKpPk`jY@kk@@k@2(R*RD+R"^dMddot! !! 777 z!77! !!!! o|.@XdCo!!!!!!!    oooo!7777!!!!!!!77!!!!!!!!!    77777777oooo7 o o o o o!!!!77!!!!   !!!!!!!!   ! o!! !!!7!Kdx++o"^]]v(Joo]o]]]]R];]]]J]JJJo]oWoo]ooM8oooooooooo]M(]]]]]]]]]]]]]J]]JJJJJM;ooo]]];Jo]Ku]o{z@ooMooMMJoM"^]o(]oo]o]]ooE];o]o]o]]](o]o]ooM8oooooooooo]M(]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]M;ooo;]oKu]o{zOMooMM]M"|NP^}}iNNi2iii2iiiN2iiii2idK}ZyyyyIeTeeee.. e|W.. eeee..IeeeWWW\<J.2FE.sjW rCw"(.<Y ~.cWW<.  W<Y.e<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<....................            WWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWW\FwYY2\,R-Rf.R/R "^]]v(Joo]o]]]]R];]]]J]JJJo]oWoo]ooM8oooooooooo]M(]]]]]]]]]]]]]J]]JJJJJM;ooo]]];Jo]Ku]o{z@ooMooMMJoM"^]o(]oo]o]]ooE];o]o]o]]](o]o]ooM8oooooooooo]M(]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]M;ooo;]oKu]o{zOMooMM]M"^JY~JYYhJYJJYYJYJYJYJJJhYhKhYJYY -YYYYYYYYYYJ JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ hhhYYYJhYK]JYca? YY  J "^]o(]oo]o]]ooE];o]o]J]o]ooM8oooooooooo]M(]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]M;ooo;]oKu]o{zOMooMM]M2<7R8R:29R"^h[hht---DDD-DD-----ttt[-\hFt-------tttt-DDDD-------DD---------DDDDDDDDttttDttttt----DD-------------t-----D-Kh}77t"^SoMoooSoS]oo6;Mo]ooo]o]oIoSooM8oooooooooo]M]]]]]]]]]]]]]MoooM]oKuSodn]MooMMoM"^NhhhhNhNWWWhy&hWhhhWWWhyW>hNhh84hhhhhhhhhhWhWhWhWhWhWhWhWhWyWWWWWhhhyyyyWWW&WhyW"^h[hht---DDD-DD-----t;M\hFt-------tttt-DDDD-------DD---------DDDDDDDDttttDttttt----DD-------------t-----D-Kh}77t2<nT& =R ?R0"^NhhhhNhNWWWhy&hWhhSa>hNhh84hhhhhhhhhhWhWhWhWhWhWhWhWhWyWWWWWhhhyyyyWWW&WhyW"^KdzdddKdKSSSdu dSdddSSSduS<dKdd,2ddddddddddS dSdSdSdSdSdSdSdSuSSSSS ddduuuuSSSSduS"^Nh8hhhNhNWhh"y&8hWhhhWhWyh{E{hNhh84hhhhhhhhhhW8yWyWyWyWyWyWyWyWWWWWW8yyyyhhh8WyhKmNh^gW8hh88h8"^Nh8hhhNhNWhh"y&8hWhha}{E{hNhh84hhhhhhhhhhW8yWyWyWyWyWyWyWyWWWWWW8yyyyhhh8WyhKmNh^gW8hh88h82@PQVn"9 ^8CRddCCCdn2n28dddddddddd88nnnYzoCNzoozzC8C^dCYdYdYCdd88d8ddddCN8ddddY`(`lK\2[dCYddddd7>dd$YYdCCddooCYqnnn!8nBBnnnyyPn7c1RyyXyycnnnndccccccccMMMMMMMMMMMMы~nyRzcXcyhFBnnshcnntnvyX~Xsyn~XyBBnss~y~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~XXXXXXXyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyBBBBBBBBBBBBnnnnnnnssssssssssssFFn"9 ^,5APP|555PX(X(,PPPPPPPPPP,,XXXGtkktbYtt5>tbttYtkYbttttb5,5KP5GPGPG5PP,,P,|PPPP5>,PPtPPGM MWKJ(HP5GPPPPP,2P~~PGGP55PPYY5GxxxxiZXXXr,X55XXXr{rrr``@X,rO(Bn``{rrrrF{{{``iOXXXrrrnnnXPOOOOOOOO============oejX`BbOhFhOz`wS85tXnX\vSgOxX{X]X_`FeFn\z`rXn{neF`55X\\nen`reeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeFFFFFFF````````````````````555555555555XXXXXXX\\\\\\\\\\\\nnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnohz8xn{8nX"^KdzdddKdKSSSdu dSddP]<dKdd,2ddddddddddS dSdSdSdSdSdSdSdSuSSSSS ddduuuuSSSSduS"^lxlQxllllDQ 3O Ki; hUU! Q9!!!x ~e~ilHl|QQQQQH3    ||||hUUUUQQQQ!QO iU!QQQ3333O     KKKKKKii||~|; ~ ~ ~ ~ ~hhhhUUf!!!   QQQQQQi!!!!O  ~h! !!O UQ22+WRrYR!a%f$("^Kd,dddKdKSddu,dSdddSdSudvBvdKdd,2ddddddddddS,uSuSuSuSuSuSuSuSSSSSS,uuuuddd,SudKiKdZcS,dd,,d,"^Kd,dddKdKSddu,dSdd]xvBvdKdd,2ddddddddddS,uSuSuSuSuSuSuSuSSSSSS,uuuuddd,SudKiKdZcS,dd,,d,"9 ^*2=KK}u222KR&R&*KKKKKKKKKK**RRRClddl\Sll2:l\llSldS\llll\2*2FK2CKCKC2KK**K*uKKKK2:*KKlKKCHHQKE&DK2CKKKKK)/KwwKCCK22KKSS2CqqqqcURRRk*R11RRRkskkkZZ<R){kJ%>gwZZskkkkB{sssZZcJRRRkkkgggRKJJJJJJJJ::::::::::::h_cRZ>\JbBbJsZoN51mRgRVoNaJqRsRWRYZB_BhVrZkRwgsg_BZ11RVVg_hZk___________________BBBBBBBZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZ111111111111RRRRRRRVVVVVVVVVVVVgggggggggggggggggggghbs5qhs5hR"9 ^.8DSS888S\*\*.SSSSSSSSSS..\\\Jxooxf]xx8Axfxx]xo]fxxxxf8.8NS8JSJSJ8SS..S.SSSS8A.SSxSSJP!PZKM*LS8JSSSSS.4SSJJS88SS]]8J~~~~n^\\\w.\77\\\wwwweeC\.wR)EreewwwwIeenR\\\wwwrrr\SRRRRRRRR@@@@@@@@@@@@tin\eEfRmIlRe|W;7y\r\`{WlR}\\a\ceIiIs`ev\rriIe77\``risewiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiIIIIIIIeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee777777777777\\\\\\\````````````rrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrtm;}s;s\28oRd+pR.qR2yRZ5"^lxixllllDQ!9i iiQ ii i9 !QQ!!!x        ilH QQQQQQ9    i iiiiQ Q Q Q !Qi ii!QQQ9999i     iiiiiii i Q      i i i i iii999    !!!Q Q Q Q Q Q i!!!!i  i 9 !!!i iQ KlxDDb  "^W`4!`ssWsWgWW!!![!!![ss`sss4s!kksWss[:sssssssssss[ssss!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!sssssssss!!!!!![!sss[!!s!s!!KW`O[Z[s["^lxixllllDQ!9i iiQ ii i9 !QQ!!!x!!![!!![lH QQQQQQ9    i iiiiQ Q Q Q !Qi ii!QQQ9999i     iiiiiii i Q      i i i i iii999    !!!Q Q Q Q Q Q i!!!!i  i 9 !!!i iQ KlxDDb  "^No$$$$NNiiN2iNiNiN2iNNN2ooooi$T2NNNNNiNNNNiiiiiNNi2NNNNiiiiiNNNNiioNoooooiiiiiiiNNNN222iiiiiiiN222ioiiN2NNiiK 2qq`o2EzR8R0<R?B"^i$$$$2iiiiN2ii2iNiN2iNNN2$222222222$T2iiiiiiNNNNi22222i2i2i2i2Nii222Niiiiiiii2NNNN222222i2i2i22222i2i2i2i222iiiNNNN222i2i2i2i2i2i2N222i22i2iN2NNi22i2K2qqw22"^HH\:WWeHWHHHHHHHHz:H:::WHWDWWHWW+WWWWWWWWWWHHHHHHHHHHHHHH:HH:::::WWWHHH:WHK[HW`_2WWWW:W"^HW{HWWeHWHHWWHWHWHWHHHeWeIeWHWW+WWWWWWWWWWHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHeeeWWWHeWK[HW`_>WWH"9 ^:EUhhEEEhr4r4:hhhhhhhhhh::rrr]tEQttŖE:EbhE]h]h]Ehh::h:hhhhEQ:hhhh]d*dqK`4^hE]hhhhh:Ahh&]]hEEhhttE]vrrr#:rEErrr~~Sr9g3V~~[~~grrrrhggggggggPPPPPPPPPPPPёr~Vg[g~mIErrxmgrryr{~[[x~r[~EErxx~[[[[[[[~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~EEEEEEEEEEEErrrrrrrxxxxxxxxxxxxIIr2[F"IO{U"9 ^(K@ )"?9 @ "^JMn%%%MMM9M^MMMMMn9nn9n^%99999''%%%r%%%%%%%%%%MMMMMr9MMMMM9MM9MMM9999MMMMn9M9nnnnnr%%%M9M9M9M9M9999n%M9M9M9KBv%cZ;%%r%%r99rn%r"^;;vvyy;y;;vvvvvvvvvv;;v~22r2;7v2rr22.;;;vvv7vv;vv7vvvvy7;v72777{'{y;yymyyyyyyyyyy;vvvvvm27vvvv;;;;;;;;2vrvrvrvrv2v2v2v2v7v2vrrv7vvv272727272vvvvvrvrvrvrvrvrv2v2v;;;;;;;77vvvvv2v2v2v2vrvrvm.2y2y2y7777;;;2v2v2v2v2v2v.277772vv2v2y7;772vrv2vK;avyvvvvvvCCvyyvmyyvvm77mym2^{nRhqRtR x"^r{brr~~~I//IIIIIII/IIII~~~~b~I[rL~IIIII//~~~~IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII////IIIIIIIII~~~~I~~~~~IIIIIII///~~~IIIIIIIII~I/~IIIII"^%%%%%%IM^MMMMM%%%%9%%%r%%%%%%%%%%rMMMMMMMMMMrMMMM%%%M999M%MMKB%cZ99r%%rr9r"^uu/uuuu////G/u/^/GG//uuuuuuGvuFu/////u/uuuuuuuu/GGGG//////GG////////GGGGGG//uuuuuuuu/uuuuu////GG/////////G/u///G/Ku66du"^r{rr~I/II/bbb/IbbI/IIII/~~~{IdrL~IIIIIII////~~~~IbbbbIIIIIIIbbIIIIIIIII////bbbbbbbb~~~~b/~/~/~/~/~IIIIbbIIII///IIIIIIII///I/~II/IIIbIKrTT~2R{~V"^uuu]uuuuu//G/u^/GG//uuu]u]]]^u/muFuu/uuuuuuuu/GGGG/////GG/////GGGGGG//uuuuu]uu]]]]]////GG///uuu////////]//u/G/Ku66P]"m^8C_oo8CCNu8C88ooooooooooCCuuuzÐz8ozzzC8Cuo8ozozoCzz88o8zzzzNoCzooodN8NuC8CC!CCCCCCCCCCz8oooooȲooooo88888888zzzzzzzzzoozzzoooooooozoooozzzzzzzz88888888ooz8z8z8z8z8zzzzzzȽNNNoooozCzCzCzzzzzzozdzdzdzz8zNozCoozzzKF8ooCzoooooJIoo0ddoCCoozz8d"m^//<__q&99Bc/9//__________//ccc_qq{{qh{/Uq_{q{qh{qqqh///P_&__U__/__&&U&____9U/_U{UUU9,9c9/999999999999h/q_q_q_q_q_{Uq_q_q_q_////////{_____{_{_{_{_qUq_{_h_qUq_q_q_{U{U{U{U{_q_q_q_q_______{_{_/////&//UqU_&_&_&_&_&{_{_{_{___{9{9{9qUqUqUqUh/h/h/{_{_{_{_{_{_{qUhUhUhU{__&{_{9qUh/qUqU{__{_K</[_9h_____?>_}}_ 99_99__UU&9"m^//<__q&99Bc/9//__________//ccc_qq{{qh{/Uq_{q{qh{qqqh///P_&__U__/__&&U&____9U/_U{UUU9,9c9/999999999999h/q_q_q_q_q_{Uq_q_q_q_////////{_____{_{_{_{_qUq_{_h_qUq_q_q_{U{U{U{U{_q_q_q_q_______{_{_/////&//UqU_&_&_&_&_&{_{_{_{___{9{9{9qUqUqUqUh/h/h/{_{_{_{_{_{_{qUhUhUhU{__&{_{9qUh/qUqU{__{_K</[_9h_____?>_}}_ 99_99__UU&923Br 7oC2o\  PCXPTLDDD]Z\PPPs y.]8*C]\  PCPLt 4oi- > o2PkC Pu ?i- 2p}wC v IS?%X  Pg9CP w c%}%?%X  Pg9CP\x e,}. ,0n p-CD =SF<2PAPDy {y<Α2PAPz HS?CZ^0L xCX { HS?SdHd xC&| <YJh P['C P &} wCh0C P['C@P d~ {[n[X pTC@ :uC2%nFuX  Pg9CXP :qC2CFq0L xCXX\ GS?.0n p-C WdK%^iX  Pg9CPL 1sC8 8:s2PkCXPLy'\5, \2PkCP 1sC8 8:s2PkCXP /xC8:x2p}wCXeL:PC 4c2PkCP 8PCQ2p}wC IYCS\  PC P%"!(R(\  PC@P5F54  p(AC@6uk u4  p(AC5F54  p(AC@DAYJ<+2PA PD#<#2PA@PWkPX\  PCP:vG5S;v\  PCP IYCS\  PC P!IYCG4  p(AC $:|G5;|4  p(AC#"IYCG4  p(AC $#md1.\  PCP&#mdF?.4  p(AC(WkPX4  p(AC'&#mdF?.4  p(AC(L~)`8. d`2PkCP*g21ffLQo] T2PkCP,+No]12p}wCQo]2x(CX-No]{2x4vC/>YJ2x4vC .-No]{2x4vC/Ld!M,% |M2PkCP0)~)`8. d`2PkCP*1'd8.Od2p}wC4fP,%Q}|P2p}wC32'd8.Od2p}wC49tE4-t\  PCqP6:@5/rhZ1[\  PCP7/rhN.[4  p(AC9[oS'|4  p(AC87/rhN.[4  p(AC9UhNB\  PCP=<DS?뮝\  PCP;:UhNB\  PCP<UhNB4  p(AC?DS?4  p(AC>=UhNB4  p(AC?9yE4-y4  p(ACqBy.a8* a4  p(ACA@9yE4-y4  p(ACqBLq%V2* |V2PkCPc^_baW!C(3AC\  PChPFEKW!F($AF4  p(ACh<X B( AB*f9 xChXGW!C(AC9 xIChIG6 69 xIC"HGW!C(AC9 xIChIF6 6\  PC"PJDW!C(3AC\  PChPFEKt,Y5(Y\  PCP`MSt,]5(]4  p(ACO]#J+ $WJ4  p(ACNMt,]5(]4  p(ACOD1mC8<K:m2PAXPQDy'W5,<+kW2PAP]#G+ 7WG\  PCPRLt,Y5(Y\  PCPMSRdK#\  PCPWVAP<Ӯ\  PCPUTRdK#\  PCPVRdK#4  p(ACYAP<G4  p(ACXWRdK#4  p(ACY7tC2t4  p(ACX[MZ7tC2t4  p(ACX[L7oC2o\  PCXPTLDZ\P<5nC2Kn*f9 xCXXLD4  42PkCPq%V2*]V2x(CX<v*X5(k5X*f9 xCXDq%R2*<#pR2PAPas#Z2*MZ2p}wCL[E(! VE2PkChPz&`5,I`2p}wCd/xC8:x2p}wCXeD~)[8.<i[2PAP~)`8.[`2x(CXhl'd8.d2x4vCjfP,%ڌ|P2x4vCih'd8.d2x4vCjd!M,%Ve|M2x(CXkg~)`8.[`2x(CXhl ?H6%fwX  Pg9CPnsrm3~l%GX  Pg9CPo\5|l.RL0n p-Cq\ctW.Ce0n p-Cpo5|l.RL0n p-Cq\>H6.7w0n p-Cx ?zH6Cwz0L xCXt >H6SDwHd xCv{2f:+SGfHd xCut>H6SDwHd xCv\{2h:+.ch0n p-Cwr>H6.7w0n p-CxL{y  Ee 2PkCP{zt, ,2p}wCSnΖ*6j Hxg#CXL5}H< \(j}2PkCP~L*d:0 d2PkCP}|5}H< \(j}2PkCP~3H<j2p}wC(h:0Kh2p}wC3H<j2p}wC5}H<j}2x(CX3H<2,j2x4vC(h:0:h2x4vC3H<2,j2x4vC*d:06[d2x(CX5}H<j}2x(CXL?WH x2PkC P=WHa2p}wC DQo]< 2PAPD3rE:<oRr2PAqPD<et<"~2PAPD5vH<<jv2PAPL Zz; Ҟ 2PkCH PL & i_2PkCVP &9_2p}wCV ;xH6Dx\  PCP K|r\  PCUP K|r4  p(ACUL >fu ǭ2PkCP BbuJ2p}wC 1sC8:s2x(CXX /xC8zF:x2x4vCXL )b9/ b2PkCP)b9/.Ub2x(CX 3'3'Standard6&6&Standardius_PostScript_( نUSUK7  B5   Њ5a J ddx !b"J H H "  Bu# 2PkCH P##_2PkCiVP# Sorites #X  Pg9CP#  { B $3#7)' H H "0 A Digital Journal of Analytical Philosophy  `_ -$#wX  Pg9CmfP#Indexed and Abstracted in  THE PHILOSOPHER'S INDEX  >yISSN 1135-1349 1 Legal Deposit Registration: M 14867-1995 ;k  KH ; #mo\  PCXP##Dx\  PCP# Editor: Lorenzo Pe9a  [0 3 #X  Pg9CP#(CSIC [Spanish Academy of Sciences])  [ 2 LogicandLaw Research Group (JuriLog)H E H " [ 6YBoard of Editorial Consultants: + JeanYves B)ziau, Enrique Alonso, GuillermoHurtado,  [^ 1 ManuelLiz, RaymundoMorado, Txetxu Aus1nE  " h ;D RegularMail Address:  x <SProf. Lorenzo Pe9a 6 CSIC " Institute of Philosophy APinar 25 >E28006 Madrid C)Spain ;   j! < Fax +3491 564 52 52 5 Voice Tph +3491 411 70 60, ext 18 ;   Y% 9 #:s2PkC8XP#< http://www.sorites.org/ >  R"& 8< http://www.sorites.info/ >  R ' ;>< sorites@sorites.org > Ea  " Pk* 9H Issue #18 " February 2007  o)Ea+p-p-p- Ea#\  PCS P#ц bb 5a5a @ !b" Addx"@   o)"E` v   * <B  Sorites ($3#7)')  E`  "E` >ISSN 1135-1349 9 Issue #18 " February 2007  j 2 Copyright  by Sorites and the authors  j! ;     j 9 < http://www.sorites.org/ >  je 8   j ;< sorites@sorites.org > E` Eap-p-p-  a v  U 1  1 a  =#`2PkC)dP#  bbb IM v   o> A Sorites ($3#7)') BISSN 1135-1349  H` A Roll of Referees  ? MbRainer Bornp9!LJohannesKepler Universitaet Linz (Austria) Amedeo Contep9!\University of Pavia (Italy) Newton C.A. da Costap9!WUniversity of SMo Paulo (Brazil) Marcelo Dascalp9!XUniversity of Tel Aviv (Israel) Dorothy Edgingtonp|9![Birbeck College (London, UK) Graeme Forbesp9!HTulane University (New Orleans, Louisiana, USA) Manuel Garc1a-Carpinterop 9!XUniversity of Barcelona (Spain) Laurence Goldsteinp!9!TUniversity of Hong Kong (Hong Kong) Jorge Graciap_9!LState University of New York, Buffalo (USA) Nicholas Griffinp9!HMcMaster University (Hamilton, Ontario, Canada) Rudolf Hallerp'9!NKarlFranzensUniversitaet Graz (Austria) Terence Horganp 9!QUniversity of Memphis (Tennessee, USA) Victoria Iturraldep9!EUniv. of the Basque Country (San Sebastian, Spain) Tomis E. Kapitanp9!UNorthern Illinois University (USA) Manuel Lizp(9!HUniversity of La Laguna (Canary Islands, Spain) Peter MenziespT9!CAustralian National University (Canberra, Australia) Carlos Moyap9!YUniversity of Valencia (Spain) Kevin Mulliganp9!UUniversity of Geneva (Switzerland) JesCs PadillaGlvezp9!LJohannesKepler Universitaet Linz (Austria) Philip PettitpT9!CAustralian National University (Canberra, Australia) Graham Priestp9!IUniversity of Queensland (Brisbane, Australia) Eduardo Rabossip9!QUniversity of Buenos Aires (Argentina) DavidHillel Rubenp9!;School of Oriental and African Studies, University of London Mark Sainsburyp9!\King's College (London, UK) Daniel Schulthesspn9!RUniversity of Neuchtel (Switzerland) Peter Simonsp9!XUniversity of Leeds (Leeds, UK) Ernest Sosap_9!GBrown University (Providence, Rhode Island, USA) Friedrich Stadlerp9!PInstitut Wien Kreis  (Vienna, Austria)f(=p-p-p- #)-t\  PC5qP#=  <g A  Sorites ($3#7)') BISSN 11351349 =Issue #18 " February 2007  vz A Table of Contents  ? abX #bb" Abstracts of the Papers9! pi 9!u03 X #bb" Samples and Logical Form  by M. G. Yoes9! pi 9!u07 X #bb" May Judges Sometimes Lie? Remarks on Sorensen's Views of Vagueness and Law  by Jason Glenn9! pi 9!u10 X #bb" The Contextual Nature of Cognition and Dancy's Moral Particularism  by Mark Lovas9! pi 9!u17 X #bb" Kuhn and Metaphysical Realism  by Andrew M. Bailey9! pi 9!u27 X #bb" Nonsense and the Privacy of Sensation  by Juan Jose Acero9! pi 9!u33 X #bb" An Argument Against External Reasons  by Jonathan Anomaly9! pi 9!u56 X #bb" Judging Life and Its Value  by Brooke Alan Trisel9! pi 9!u60 X #bb" Normativity without Exception: Donald Davidson on Language and Communication  by Sonia Arribas9! pi 9!u76 X #bb" The Private Language Argument Isn't as Difficult, Nor as Dubious as Some Make Out  by Roger Harris9! pi 9!u98 X #bb" Facts, Truth, and Realism: Toward a Multilevel Theory of Knowledge  by Paul Bowyer9! p 9!t109 X #bb" A Dilemma for the Weak Deflationist about Truth  by Glen Hoffmann 9! p 9!t129  Z* X #bb" The Sorites Charter9! p 9!t138 X #bb" Release Notice9! p 9!t143 "=p-p-p-  b #5V2PkCC|P#X01Í ÍX01ÍÍ. CX1Í.X*Í. C#Co\  PCXP#Ea v 8 WB  a " Sorites  Issue #18 " February 2007issnĠ1135-1349`!%"yă   yIdddy8R WB @ a " Sorites ĠIssue #18 " February 2007. Abstracts of the papers. issnĠ1135-1349`!%"yă   yIdddyR= a  a @ Addx" a ddx @  --" yM 9j Sorites ($3#7)'), ISSN 1135-1349 >http://www.sorites.org 8Issue #18 " February 2007. Pp. 36 >WAbstracts of the Papers  tM 6!Copyright  by Sorites and the authors--#a  Ea v   s  :]  Abstracts of the Papers  Ea ;  Ea  X 9B Samples and Logical Form  X_ ?by M. G. Yoes #aThis paper concerns a puzzle about the logical form of expressions involving repeated `and's. Obvious attempts to solve the problem fail. It happens that a proper solution surprisingly requires the semantic notions of sampling and expression. I speculate that this may provide an alternative to conversational implicature. ;   X7 9# May Judges Sometimes Lie?  X >by Jason Glenn #aClearly, vagueness is an inevitable feature of natural language. The practice of law, which is necessarily done within the confines of language, must inevitably come to grips with the phenomenon of vagueness. What philosophers working with these concerns tend to debate about is the extent to which vagueness affects law and the role that vagueness plays therein. Roy Sorensen argues that vagueness in law is not functional and therefore to be avoided as much as possible by judges. Sorensen equates the decisions that judges make about borderline cases with lying. Sorensen bases his conclusions in part upon the idea that borderline cases do admit of truthvalues; it is simply the case that we do not have the means to discover these truthvalues. I find that Sorensen may be too quick on the draw in accusing judges of the moral indiscretion of lying, and that judges, though perhaps acting insincerely in a truly minimal sense, are in fact not lying. ;   X# $v The Contextual Nature of Cognition and Dancy's Moral Particularism  X,% ?by Mark Lovas #aWe can shed new light upon Jonathan Dancy's moral particularism if we frame it in  Xt' terms of Daniel Andler's recent discussion of the epistemological problem of context. Andler helps us in two specific ways. First, we can see that Dancy's work is highlighting the problem context raises for moral knowledge. This makes some criticisms of Dancy seem off the mark. Secondly, Andler's approach also helps us understand why Dancy seems reticent to provide more epistemological details. Nonetheless, the paper closes with a suggestion about the+=p-p-p- possibility of a particularist account of moral knowledge more detailed than anything Dancy has provided. ;   X /  Kuhn, Metaphysical Realism, and Reduplication  X <by Andrew M. Bailey  Xe #aI offer in this paper an analysis of one troubling passage in Thomas Kuhn's Structure  XP of Scientific Revolutions. First, I lay out a dilemma for Kuhn; that he is confronted with either an incoherent formal contradiction or a form of metaphysical antirealism. Second, using reduplicative propositions, I attempt to carve out a third reading which avoids the dilemma. Finally, I answer two objections to the coherence of my reduplicative reading. In doing this, I dismantle one reason many have found compelling to view Kuhn as a metaphysical antirealist. ;   X 3  Nonsense and the Privacy of Sensation  X < by Juan Jose Acero #aThis paper explores the socalled Epistemic Privacy Way, one of Wittgenstein's lines of attack on the very possibility of a private language. The Epistemic Privacy Way has it that sentences like `I know I am in pain' or `But I must know whether I am in pain!', among many others, cannot be used as vehicles of a sort of knowledge incorrigible and immediate. To substantiate such a criticism, Cora Diamonds views of nonsense are spelled out and a constraint, i.e. the Meaning Restricted Exportability Requirement (MRE), is distilled out of them. Beside holding, in opposition to Diamond, that MRE is compatible with the Principle of Meaning Compositionality, it is argued that sentence constituency is subject to two kinds of conditions, namely, syntagmatic and paradigmatic, which contribute to a detailed explanation of why sentences like `I know I am in pain', `It is 5 o'clock p.m. on the Sun' or `Spain is above New Zeland' could be nonsensical. Another result of making MRE to bear on this topic is a distinction between meaning and thought " a (declarative) sentence could be meaningful but express no thought at all " that echoes back Wittgenstein's distinction between depth and surface grammar. ;   X 3  An Argument against External Reasons  XM! <by Jonathan Anomaly #aIn this article I first clarify and then defend Bernard Williams' claim that all practical reasons are internal. I argue that since external reasons are incompatible with a plausible version of the oughtimpliescan principle, they are all false. Although some defend internalism by asserting that external reasons fail to explain rational action, a better defense appeals to the fact that only internal reasons are consistent with the oughtimpliescan principle. ; (p-++!!Ԍ X 8: Judging Life and Its Value  X_ ;by Brooke Alan Trisel #9Some philosophers have noted that there is a difference between the questions Is life meaningful or purposeful?  and Is life worth living?  However, what it is that makes these questions different has not been explored. Although the famed question about the meaning of life has received most of the attention, I argue that the better and more fruitful question is Is life worth living?  When addressing the question Is life worth living?  one takes into account benefits and costs that are ignored when considering the question Is life purposeful?  thereby explaining how life can be purposeless, but worth living or purposeful, but not worth living. After exploring the differences between these questions, I then evaluate various ways of determining whether life is worth living. I argue that the best method for making this determination is to ask oneself whether or not one would have chosen to live one's life. ;   X -!  Normativity without Exception: Donald Davidson on  X 8 ԚLanguageandCommunication  X =xby Sonia Arribas #9This paper deals with three texts by Donald Davidson's that discuss the issue of linguistic innovation (in metaphor and other devices) from different epistemological standpoints. I show that Davidson's theory of metaphor undergoes a crucial transformation: from an early stage in which metaphor is viewed as an unintelligible and exceptional element external to language, to a later stage in which it is conceived as intrinsic to language, and thus as potentially understandable. This tracing of Davidson's development leads me to formulate an understanding of the concepts of metaphor, literalness and linguistic renovation that follows the later Davidson. According to this formulation, both metaphor and literal meaning are comprehensible, and must therefore be said to exist in a relationship of mutualit